Friday, 3 May 2013

The Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act: what does it mean?

Last night the text of the new Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act was finally published. The copyright provisions in this Act have been hotly disputed on all sides, but most emphatically by the artistic community who claim that legislation on orphan works and extended collective licensing will threaten their livelihoods (see BBC article 'Photographers' anger at law change over orphan works'). This week has seen a lot of hysteria around the provisions of the Act, and a petition has even been set up to get these provisions repealed, but I wanted to wait until the full text was out before posting my thoughts. So what do the copyright provisions in the Act mean?

Orphan Works

Discussions on orphan works have been happening for a while. Last year, the EU brought out a Directive on Orphan Works which went into some detail about diligent searches to discover authors/creators, appropriate record-keeping and (where possible) rights registries, and is particularly keen for searches to be able to be conducted across borders. However, the Directive neatly dodges the issue of artistic works as it does not include them in its scope. The Directive must be implemented into UK law within 2 years, but is without prejudice to any national laws drafted in the meantime in relation to orphan works (so it wouldn't restrict the provisions of the ERR Act).

So what does the ERR Act do? Well, it extends section 116 of the CDPA (which is to do with licensing schemes and licensing bodies) and allows for the Secretary of State (by way of regulations) to permit a person or persons to authorise the grant of licences for the use of orphan works. I have to say, I find it curious that the text of this new section (116A) deviates quite significantly from the text of section 116, and appears quite confusing - why not continue with 'licensing body' rather than 'person', for example? The definitions are already there, but not so for the new section, so I wonder who will have responsibility in authorising these licences. These regulations will set out the scope of the diligent search that must be undertaken before a work can be declared orphan, and a licence subsequently granted will not be an exclusive licence. The regulations may also specify 'other matters to take into account' (one would assume that the potential for the orphan work to have been stripped of its metadata would be part of this), provide for royalties to be paid should the author/creator come forward, and provide for circumstances where a licence should be withdrawn.

Extended Collective Licensing

The ERR Act adds another new section to the CDPA in the form of 116B which will in similar fashion to 116A allow collecting rights societies such as the Copyright Licensing Agency to apply to the Secretary of State to be able grant licences to organisations to use works where the copyright is not owned by the collecting rights society or its authors/publishers. Quite how this works in practice is unclear; does it apply to works of foreign origin, for example? If it does there could potentially be jurisdictional issues. The licence granted could cover any or all of the rights in copyright and could actually in practice be very difficult to administer, given that rightsholders can specifically request not to be included in any grant of extended licence (and one assumes there would be many opting out of this particular one). It is also not clear how this section works with orphan works; could they fall under an extended collective licence, for example? Perhaps the regulations will make that more clear.

How do these regulations come about?

The ERR Act states that regulations will come about via statutory instrument that must be laid before and approved by a resolution of each House of Parliament. So there will be more parliamentary fun to be had over the next 12 months or so when it is assumed these regulations will be drafted.

Some thoughts... 

The orphan works issue has come about because of the large quantities of works with no defined author held by archives, museums and galleries. In the digital age, with the seamless technology available, these heritage institutions want to be able to make these works available to the public in ways which would ensure their preservation but also put them on display for the world to see. The cost of trying to trace the rightsholders for these works is disproportionate and most smaller archives and museums are forced to abandon projects because the risk of infringement is too great. Ideally, there should be a solution which enables heritage material to be put into the public space because the public funds its preservation. However, the ERR Act will require museums and archives to pay a licensing fee up front to put orphan works from their collections online, and given that there may be a lot of orphan works which will probably remain unclaimed, there is a question about where the money goes, who holds it and who profits from it. At present, it doesn't look like the people directly involved (i.e. the creators who create the work or the institutions who hold and preserve it) will receive much if anything at all.

There should also be a mechanism in the regulations to prevent large corporate organisations evading the cost of photographs from stock image galleries by applying for an orphan works licence. This would have serious consequences for the photographic community and is not (in my opinion) what the purpose of orphan works legislation was supposed to be about.

There's actually a very good balanced article over at the Economist's blog which takes into account the photographers' views and lawyers' views and echoes some of my thoughts on the issues.


My suggestions to authors and creators are: 

1. Be vigilant. The ERR Act doesn't abolish copyright, nor does the UK Government want all your works for free, but you need to be aware of these new licensing schemes to ensure that you get what you want. At the end of the day, your work is yours, and unless you assign copyright, you have the right to exploit it in any way you desire. 

2. Protect your work. Do everything you can to ensure that you are known as the author or creator of the work (I appreciate this is more difficult for visual artists, but there is some excellent advice from photographers in this article on  

3. Watch for the creation of the regulations. This will scope out the definition of diligent search, and you will still have a chance to have your say as they must pass through Parliament.

4. Follow the money. The whole of the UK is watching to see exactly where the funds from the use of orphan works will be going, and if you are an author or creator you may be able to find ways of tapping into those funds. It may not be easy, but there are enough author and creator organisations to carry some weight in this area. 

Finally, there is already an up-and-coming excellent schemes which is looking at the issue of licensing of copyright works as a whole. The UK Government has given £150,000 to the Copyright Hub (a creation which has arisen following Richard Hooper's investigative work into copyright licensing) which aims to be a portal to manage rights and find rightsholders. I believe that this will feature in the regulations for a diligent search. 


  1. Sorry if this is a stupid question, but under this legislation would it be possible for me to set up a company that strips metadata from images I've found on the internet, then sells licenses to use those images as they are "orphan works"? Assuming 'diligent search' turns out to be badly defined, that is.

    Not that I want to do this, it's just from the various articles about this it seems like it would be possible for someone to do it

    1. You could, but metadata stripping is actually illegal (it's right there in the law) so a company set up to do this specifically would be breaking the law and could be sued by everyone.

  2. Sorry, yes - what I meant was if the company was stripping metadata secretively, then claiming the images were orphan works (and providing evidence of a cursory 'diligent' search).

    So I would be able to claim copyright licensing money for works that I had no business in creating, simply by virtue that they're orphan works? That seems incredibly unjust..

  3. Nicely written, but you are naive if you think that the sole (or major) motivator for licensing orphan works is the cultural sector - Google et al have been lobbying hard for the past few years to get this to work in their favour and they have very deep pockets. Sadly, Cameron and the rest have been swayed by their arguments in the interests of 'innovation', one of those catch-words that means nothing, at the expense of creators' rights. We, as creators, will have to opt out of any Extended Collective Licensing schemes that come along and do more work to ensure that what we make is protected as far as possible. Yet again, the onus will be on the small guy to do the leg-work.

    Has it never occurred to anyone that the right thing to do might be to not use a work at all if the creator/author cannot be traced?

  4. Excellent written work will always be appreciated

  5. Good post. I like it. It was interesting to read it. Great thank's author for sharing…

  6. This is a great web site. Good sparkling user interface and very informative blogs. I will be coming back in a bit, thanks for the great article. I have found it enormously useful..
    happy wheels| happywheels| happy wheels unblocked| happy wheels demo| happy wheels| happywheels| happy wheels unblocked| happy wheels demo
    tetris| tetris games| tetris unblocked| unblocked tetris| monster high games| monsterhighgames| monster high| monsterhigh

  7. Like a fairytale weaved and spun with magic threads, the story of KHAS started with a dream over half a century back. A subsidiary of the Sadaqat Group, that has won respect and awards all over the world, the vision of Khas is to make the same quality available here in Pakistan.
    Boys bedding
    Girls bedding
    Cot sets

  8. Your site is truly intriguing and motivation to numerous. I'll looking forward for a greater amount of your posts. Keep it up!
    friv10 | frivgames | friv100 games

  9. Your site is truly intriguing and motivation to numerous. I'll looking forward for a greater amount of your posts. Keep it up!
    wheely | zoxy club | twizl games | papalouie online
    juegos zoxy |

  10. A great possibility for me and it was a superb knowledge to view this site.
    Papalouie Very difficult to uncover these beneficial web page or web site. Moto X3M 3I have many devices and achieving proper picture of these worked well and energy continues to be seeing about this weblog. Often my own intend to make my personal site as well as my own enjoyment is growing due to this page. I we do hope you may well be more effective.

  11. I liked it so much and very interesting, too! Thanks for sharing the experience.
    Wonderful post, really great tips and advice.
    friv 3
    friv 4 school
    kizi 2

  12. You made such a fascinating piece to peruse, giving each subject illumination for us to pick up information. Much obliged for imparting the such data to us to peruse this steel bends

  13. Awesome post! I am really preparing to over this data, is exceptionally useful my companion. Additionally incredible blog here with the majority of the profitable data you have. Keep doing awesome doing here. Helix House

  14. Astounding employment once more from you. You simply continue giving awesome articles. You are by a long shot the most reliable article essayist that I have seen. I am dependably watchful for your articles. Expectation will see one all the more soon. Much obliged.the thyroid secret

  15. Read that again - Knowing what to do to your site in order for Google to properly recognize and categorize your site is the first step in achieving top rankings in Google. Internet Marketing SEO, and in particular, Google SEO is the key. The easier your make your site to be understood by Google, the better chances you'll have of getting top spots in Google's index. Google search engine marketing is the answer to getting your site found.

    While Label SEO

  16. Look for a dealerships that sells cars of that age. Older cars are usually sold at small corner used car lots in low income neighborhoods. Newer used cars are sold at big used car lots run by new car dealers.

    compramos tu coche

  17. Amazing Blog! I might want to thank for the endeavors you have made in composing this post. I am trusting a similar best work from you later on also. Digital Photography Basics

  18. Much thanks to you since you have been willing to impart data to us. we will dependably welcome all you have done here in light of the fact that I know you are extremely worried with our
    Photography workshops

  19. Prune deciduous ones in late winter early spring taking off any misplaced or crossing branches. Evergreen ones lightly in mid late spring. Little or no pruning is usually necessary.

  20. Great post! I am actually getting ready to across this information, is very helpful my friend. Also great blog here with all of the valuable information you have. Keep up the good work you are doing here. cpne nursing

  21. I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work.
    make my assignment

  22. I might want to thank for the endeavors you have made in composing this post

  23. I like your post. It really useful with me. Thanks for sharing these useful information!

  24. You’ve written nice post, I am gonna bookmark this page, thanks for info. I actually appreciate your own position and I will be sure to come back here.

  25. I was very impressed by this post, this site has always been pleasant news. Thank you very much for such an interesting post. Keep working, great job! In my free time, I like play game: What about you?

  26. Thanks for the information you shared. Please share useful information with your friends regularly

  27. This article is really fantastic and thanks for sharing the valuable post.

  28. I am looking for my memories through the stories, the narrative of people. I feel it is difficult but I will try.

  29. Hola! I've been following your web site for a while now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Austin Tx! Just wanted to say keep up the great work!
    SEO consultant Singapore

  30. your blog is nice Cracked or broken iPhone or Samsung screens can easily make you go banana. Difficulty in finding the right repair shop intensifies the gravity of matter further. So, it’s time to reveal the most renowned repair center of UK, Mobilerepairs4u. The company provides smooth iPhone Screen Repair by swapping infected part with original quality replacements. Same quality of procedures is ensured for Samsung S4 screen replacement and Galaxy S6 edge screen repair. Besides perfect repair and replacements, customers are also entitled to 12months warranty, two way free postage, and no fix no fee policy. Don’t miss a chance and book your deal now!

  31. your blog is very nice Cracked or broken iPhone or Samsung screens can easily make you go banana. Difficulty in finding the right repair shop intensifies the gravity of matter further. So, it’s time to reveal the most renowned repair center of UK, Mobilerepairs4u. The company provides smooth iPhone Screen Repair by swapping infected part with original quality replacements. Same quality of procedures is ensured for Samsung S4 screen replacement and Galaxy S6 edge screen repair. Besides perfect repair and replacements, customers are also entitled to 12months warranty, two way free postage, and no fix no fee policy. Don’t miss a chance and book your deal now!
    iphone 4s power button not working

  32. your article is very nice and fantastic Want to get best deals for your used or broken smartphones? Compare at to

    get the best price for your mobile phone in Uk. Sellthemobile is the Uk's best mobile phone

    recycling price comparison website. - Mobile Phone Recycling Comparison - Brands: Apple,

    Samsung you guys must visit this site
    recycle iphone 5s 16gb

  33. Posts shared useful information and meaningful life, I'm glad to be reading this article and hope to soon learn the next article. Have a good day guy
    Feel free to visit my website, you can play
    Friv games for school
    kizi school

  34. Thank you for such a sweet tutorial - all this time later, I've found it and love the end result. I appreciate the time you spent sharing your skills.

  35. SmartBazar Online shopping web site offers an opportunity to buy and receive your best stuffs at door step. An important thing is to consider discount offers and take profit from it. In Pakistan, online shopping sellers supply quite a lot of products like clothing, tablets, shoes, electronics, lawns and much more. It inform us to purchase few merchandise which might be listed on shopping websites are non-negotiable. This makes online shopping store clear and offers the chance to check prices of different merchandise as a way to find the very best deals. SmartBazar provide individuals advantages from their products that may rate the respective on their shopping for and selling experience. In the marketplace, online mobile shopping in Pakistan has by no means been easier.

    home shopping

  36. Alot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything that I'm interested in, but I'm most definately interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know. Nice! thank you so much! Thank you for sharing.

  37. Great post,Thanks for providing us this great knowledge,Keep it up.


  38. I have read your article, the information you give is very interesting.

  39. An excellent information provided thanks for all the information i must say great efforts made by you. thanks a lot for all the information you provided.

  40. The reason I ask is because your layout seems different then most blogs and I'm looking for something unique. P.S My apologies for getting off-topic but I had to ask!
    Hello just wanted to give you a quick heads up.

    study english in the usa

  41. Try to get some borax. Its in the clothes washing detergent and chemical sales supply area in most grocery stores. If not try to get a powdered soap with some borax in it. Read the labels.

    manhattan pest control